Jennifer Howard laughing

Jennifer Howard

Writer, editor, journalist.

  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • RSS
  • Twitter
  • Mastodon
  • Home
  • About
  • Blog
  • Books
  • Writing
    • Journalism
    • Fiction
  • Editing
  • Contact

Open Peer Review in the Times (and, oh yes, in the Chronicle)

August 24, 2010

Today’s New York Times has a front-page story about scholars challenging the old-school system of peer review (“Scholars Test Web Alterntive to Peer Review”). The story focuses on an experiment at Shakespeare Quarterly, the leading journal of Shakespeare studies. The journal put some submitted articles online and opened them up for public comment before deciding whether to publish them.

I’m happy to see this subject getting front-page treatment in the NYT. I’m even happier to say that I wrote a story about SQ and open peer review for the Chronicle a month ago (“Leading Humanities Journal Debuts ‘Open’ Peer Review and Likes It”). I’m biased, of course, but let me suggest that you’ll get a more nuanced picture from my story. Which ran first. A month ago. Did I mention that?

Two of the scholars mentioned in the NYT story, Dan Cohen (@dancohen) of George Mason University’s Center for History and New Media and Kathleen Fitzpatrick (@kfitz) of Pomona College, are worth following on Twitter for their thoughts on transforming how scholarship is published and shared. You’ll find more on open peer review at the MediaCommons site; MediaCommons hosted and advised the SQ experiment. Claire Potter, a k a Tenured Radical, has a post on her blog about the SQ venture and what it would take to reform scholarly publishing.

If you have thoughts on open peer review–or come across other experiments with it–please share them in the comments section. I expect this is a subject I will be writing about again soon.

Filed Under: Academe

Previous Post

Hyperabundance and Scarcity, or Enough Is Enough

Next Post

Fawn Hall Meets Inbox Zero

Recent Writing

  • Schools of Thought Control
  • The Publishing Ecosystem in the Digital Era: On John B. Thompson’s BOOK WARS
  • A paler shade of white: HAVING AND BEING HAD by Eula Biss

Recent Posts

  • May newsletter: analog intelligence
  • February newsletter: Purple, green, and gold
  • January newsletter: Making space

Get my newsletter

Get updates on what I'm working on and what I'm thinking about. Sign up and spread the word. Thanks!

Subscribe

About Jen

Jen Howard sitting in front of a brick wall. She is smiling.

Writer, journalist, editor, gadabout. Book- and nature lover. Washingtonian. LLC. Read more ยป

Latest Posts

  • May newsletter: analog intelligence
  • February newsletter: Purple, green, and gold
  • January newsletter: Making space
  • December newsletter: Routines vs. resolutions
  • November newsletter: Platform fatigue

Follow Me

  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • RSS
  • Twitter
  • Mastodon
Tweets by JenHoward

Content is © Jennifer Howard or respective owners | Site by Rocketkoi